Step recording

A shortcut, either keyboard or mouse (mouse would be a faster workflow), that pastes whatever notes you currently have pressed on your MIDI input device, into the piano-roll.

Example: I want a C major chord. I play a C major on the keyboard, hover over a chosen point on the time grid with my mouse and activate the shortcut. A C major chord is pasted in.

This is not necessarily telling Bitwig to understand chords from the input, rather just flatly pasting whatever keys are currently pressed on your MIDI keyboard, with the length of the previously-selected MIDI note.

What problem(s) would this feature resolve?

Hugely accelerated workflow with harmonies for people with a little keyboard experience

How does this feature fit in Bitwig as a product?

Fits with the image of finding new and efficient ways to work fast and creative in the DAW, and the theme of supplementing creativity with technology

Is there already an alternative way to achieve this on Bitwig?

Apart from recording very slowly and editing very slowly, I’m not entirely sure. I haven’t found one. If there is, it’s obscure to me.

Could it be implemented using Bitwig components or APIs, without Bitwig team’s support?

I am not experienced enough to answer this.

Could it be provided by a VST or something else reasonably integrated with Bitwig?

No.

Are there other products that offer this feature?

Logic implements something similar: Logic: Step Recording - YouTube

EXAMPLE IMAGE:
image

2 Likes

This is an interesting idea. I wonder whether there is a way to do this already.

I think Ableton offers this feature. I saw it once in a Video and was very envious.
Would be great.

It should be possible to implement this using the API. DrivenByMoss can inserted and build midi clips with the step sequencer on the controller, so it’s possible to enter notes using the API.
I thought about building it once but then shied away from it. Maybe I’ll try someday, I’ll post here if I do so and Bitwig has not done it itself by them.

@Worldwave I think your request is very clear already. Can you just remove the use of first person and change it for a neutral form (i.e. referring to “the user”), please? This way your request becomes everyone’s request.

An image would be nice as well, to feature this request on the main page.

It wasn’t ableton but logic and is called Step Recording.
I edited the post to insert this under Are there other products that offer this feature?.

1 Like

image
Here’s the picture. Unfortunately I can’t edit the post anymore it seems.

1 Like

Sorry for the silence, I was away.

@Worldwave you should be able to edit your post now.

Done. Hoping this gets to the team! Would be excited to work with it.

2 Likes

Bitwig is afak the only daw without this feature.

1 Like

@robisme at least you can vote for it! See the top left box with the number votes.

1 Like

My bad. On mobile version I wasn’t seeing it :wink:

1 Like

I voted for this. I’m astonished it doesn’t have more votes, to be honest. Step recording is an invaluable workflow feature and no DAW should be without it. I’m not sure you need to click the mouse: you could simply press down the notes you want and have them added with the last duration at the next position as well. This could be implemented by building the chord from all the note-on events until all of them also receive a note-off.

Bonus extra: a “rest” button so you can skip to the next position without entering anything…

5 Likes

the lack of this feature genuinely makes me tempted to switch back to ableton after recently trying to switch to bitwig. creating complex chord progressions is so much slower in bitwig and my music has suffered as a result.

Mindblowing to me that you cant do this in bitwig. Seems like an easy thing to implement. Its another one of the key things that keeps me using ableton.

Bitwig has potential to be LEAPS AND BOUNDS better than ableton. Just needs a few more things like this and midi capture.

Meanwhile… has anyone tried to use a step sequencer plugin to record their steps, and then move the MIDI notes to the arranger or clip launcher when you are happy about them?

The lack here is very annoying. It makes it take ten times longer to enter a sequence of chords and notes. Dragging and clicking with the mouse is very slow, too slow. As is trying to get midi clips from another DAW. (Reaper and Ableton both have nice ways, and I wish all DAWs would offer both approaches: Reaper auto advances the grid interval without pressing keys, which is quick for some things when all notes are the same length, not for others; Ableton advances when moving the cursor with arrow keys.)

1 Like

@PercyThePenguin please add you vote to this wish by clicking the vote box in the top left corner. Everyone gets 10 votes.

I support this even though I am out of votes ATM